Energy Risk Commodity Rankings 2023: adapting to new market dynamics
Winners of the 2023 Commodity Rankings provided reliability when clients faced extreme change
Click here to view tables
Commodity market participants experienced head-spinning change over the past year. Decades-old trade routes were upended and supply chains weakened following Russia’s February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, while Covid-19 lockdowns in China continued to disrupt supply and demand norms.
As oil and gas prices spiralled, markets, particularly in Europe, became subject to higher levels of government and regulatory scrutiny and input. Various schemes to cap retail prices have added to longer term uncertainty in the wholesale markets.
High inflation and rising interest rates also added further risk and increased the focus once again on counterparty credit risk.
The winners of this year’s Commodity Rankings have demonstrated enormous resilience in the face of such uncertainty, remaining reliable and effective in extreme conditions. Not only has carrying out risk management been more essential than ever over the past year, it has also become more difficult. Many tried and tested models have had to be overhauled or abandoned amid such change. Hedging has become more expensive and riskier with ongoing price volatility, resulting in some eye-watering margin calls.
Faced with this level of challenge, many energy producers and consumers turned to banks, large energy firms, brokers and research providers to help steer, execute and shore up their risk-management strategies. The 2023 Commodity Rankings tables show the firms deemed by their clients to have provided the best services during this extremely challenging time.
To see the Commodity Rankings tables in full, please click on the link above.
How the poll was conducted
The Energy Risk Commodity Rankings survey was live between November 2, 2022 and January 5, 2023 and received valid responses from 708 individuals. The survey asked respondents to vote for their top three dealers and brokers in any markets in which they had been active over the previous year. The rankings poll is designed to reflect market participants’ perception of a dealer or broker based on the overall quality of service they offer their clients. It is not intended to reflect volumes traded in any market. Instead, respondents vote according to a range of criteria including reliability, pricing, liquidity provision and speed of execution.
To create the final list of rankings, Energy Risk aggregates the results, weighting them by awarding three points for a first place, two points for second place and one point for third. The points are then added up and the highest-placed firms in each category are listed in the Rankings tables. The Overall Rankings (Best overall dealer and Best overall broker etc) are calculated by adding up all the points accrued to each firm across the different sections (Oil, Gas, Power etc). Following closure of the poll, the results are subject to an internal review process, which can result in categories being dropped or aggregated if they do not have enough votes. The outcome of the review is final.
More on Risk management
Energy Risk at 30: Learning from the past
Energy Risk looks back at the seminal events and developments that have shaped today’s energy markets
The 10 biggest energy risk management disasters of the past 20 years
The history of energy trading is littered with losses, bankruptcies and other misfortunes that now serve as cautionary tales. Alexander Osipovich looks back at the biggest energy risk management disasters of the past two decades and how they reshaped the industry
Past disasters can prove the value of energy risk management
Analysing failures and losses at energy firms showcases the value of consistent, high-quality risk management
How quants shaped the modern energy markets
The business models of today’s utility firms are built on quantitative analysis, but the introduction of these techniques in the 1990s was far from smooth
Interview: Vince Kaminski
Market veteran Vince Kaminski discusses the biggest risks to energy firms today and whether risk teams can ever prove their value
Mounting risk prompts refocus on integrated energy risk management
Energy firms are facing heightened risk due to shifting geopolitics, climate change and the energy transition. As market, credit and enterprise risks ramp up, the need for improved integrated risk management is growing, say risk managers
Energy supply chains seen as a growing risk
Supply chain risk is now a major concern, with some firms even viewing it as an existential threat, survey finds
Can behavioural science curb rogue traders… and compliance costs?
Instead of using surveillance to catch endless bad apples, experts urge banks to clean the barrel
