Ruled out: can regulators settle the pre-hedging debate?
Market participants are at odds over the practice and whether regulation or principles can settle the score

Rules or principles? It’s an age-old debate. And one that’s raging around the dealer practice of pre-hedging – or hedging in anticipation of a client trade.
The practice can improve or worsen the price at which a client executes its trade.
Global regulators have been asked to arbitrate. While critics want to see firmer action from them, and restrictions put in place, others see industry-guided principles as being enough to ensure fair play.
“There is potentially a problem to be fixed, but just
More on Regulation
Esma sounds out industry for ways to cut reporting burden
Markets watchdog asks consultative groups for ideas to simplify reporting rules
Why EU banks have snubbed revised green finance metric
Banks steer clear of Banking Book Taxonomy Alignment Ratio in droves
First green asset ratios come in low as EU banks protest methodology
ABN Amro only bank to break double digits in a sample of 23 lenders
Commodities surge presents UMR test for Asia’s sell side
Increased interest in commodity exotics comes amid scrutiny of margin calculation models
Some see Esma reining in position limits after review
The scope of position limits could shrink to cover just the major benchmarks, one executive argues
Burden of implementing US sanctions now firmly on energy firms
Energy firms must now screen operations of every vessel they deal with, writes maritime data expert
Shipping and energy firms revisit hedging on IMO 2020
Upcoming shipping rules set to impact fuel prices across the energy complex
The foreshocks of Brexit
As Brexit chaos continues, energy firms and traders are upping sticks and leaving the UK